Texas Cooking Logo

Fiesta® Butter Dish (Post 1986)

Butter Dish Production: -

by

Fiesta Butter Dish
Wow! I can't believe it's not a butter dish!
Fiesta collector

Guns and Butter

HLC added the butter dish to the Fiesta line in 1992. Since then, the company has made several small modifications to the shape of the dish's base, rounding the corners. In 2012 HLC added a second butter dish to the line, larger in size, to accommodate larger sizes of butter sold in parts of the United States. After a successful run, the company announced that they would officially transition to the larger 1431 covered butter dish. On May 31, 2013, along with a handful of other items, they would cease production of the 494 covered butter dish.

The Post86 Covered Butter is item number 494 (Base 716 Lid 717).

Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Daffodil Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Daffodil $38.95 2h 5m
Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Scarlet Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Scarlet $37.95 2h 26m
Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Poppy Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Poppy $36.95 2h 27m
Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Cobalt Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Cobalt $39.95 2h 27m
Fiestaware 2019 NEW Color MEADOW  XL Butter Dish Fiestaware 2019 NEW Color MEADOW  XL Butter Dish 0 $22.48 3h 1m
Fiestaware Juniper Butter Dish Base Fiesta Green Retired Small Base ONLY Fiestaware Juniper Butter Dish Base Fiesta Green Retired Small Base ONLY $15.00 3h 56m
Fiestaware Juniper Butter Dish Base Fiesta Green Retired Small Base ONLY Fiestaware Juniper Butter Dish Base Fiesta Green Retired Small Base ONLY $15.00 4h 3m
Fiestaware XL Covered Butter Dish in Ivory Fiestaware XL Covered Butter Dish in Ivory $25.00 19h
Fiestaware Persimmon Small Butter Dish Fiesta Orange 1/4 Lb. Covered Butter Fiestaware Persimmon Small Butter Dish Fiesta Orange 1/4 Lb. Covered Butter $26.99 1d 33m
COVERED BUTTER DISH sunflower yellow NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA COVERED BUTTER DISH sunflower yellow NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $34.99 1d 3h 44m
Fiesta Ware Homer Laughlin - Retired Juniper Covered Butter Dish Fiesta Ware Homer Laughlin - Retired Juniper Covered Butter Dish 1 $19.99 1d 8h 12m
Fiesta Looking  NOT SIGNED Pink Rose Covered Butter Dish  Fiesta Looking  NOT SIGNED Pink Rose Covered Butter Dish  0 $7.10 1d 10h 57m
Fiesta® Marigold Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Discontinued Retired Color Fiesta® Marigold Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Discontinued Retired Color $35.00 1d 14h 21m
 Fiesta®  Covered Butter Dish  Fiesta® Covered Butter Dish 0 $19.99 2d 1h 42m
Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Flamingo Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Flamingo $32.95 2d 3h 7m
9 Piece Fiesta turquoise Fiestaware 4 Dinner Plates 4 Side Plates 9 Piece Fiesta turquoise Fiestaware 4 Dinner Plates 4 Side Plates $55.00 2d 3h 32m
Fiesta Homer Laughlin Fiestaware ART DECO BLACK 1/4 pound Covered Butter Dish Fiesta Homer Laughlin Fiestaware ART DECO BLACK 1/4 pound Covered Butter Dish $75.00 2d 5h 50m
Homer Laughlin USA Fiesta Ware Cobalt Blue Covered Butter Dish 1 Stick Size EUC Homer Laughlin USA Fiesta Ware Cobalt Blue Covered Butter Dish 1 Stick Size EUC $24.99 2d 11h 43m
Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Lemongrass Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Lemongrass $37.95 3d 2h 27m
Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Ivory Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Ivory $36.95 3d 2h 27m
Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | White Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | White $36.95 3d 2h 27m
Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Lapis Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Lapis $37.95 3d 2h 29m
Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Shamrock Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Shamrock $37.95 3d 2h 32m
Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Slate Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Slate $38.95 3d 2h 34m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA PERIWINKLE BLUE (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 221033 Homer Laughlin FIESTA PERIWINKLE BLUE (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 221033 $64.95 3d 3h 58m
COVERED BUTTER DISH shamrock green NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA COVERED BUTTER DISH shamrock green NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $34.99 3d 5h 1m
Fiestaware Small Butter Dish - Turquoise Fiestaware Small Butter Dish - Turquoise $50.00 3d 9h 20m
Homer Laughlin Fiesta Shamrock Green Butter Dish Replacement Tray Top Broken Homer Laughlin Fiesta Shamrock Green Butter Dish Replacement Tray Top Broken $9.99 3d 10h 34m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA SUNFLOWER Extra Large 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832330 Homer Laughlin FIESTA SUNFLOWER Extra Large 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832330 $29.99 3d 13h 35m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA WHITE Extra Large 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832277 Homer Laughlin FIESTA WHITE Extra Large 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832277 $31.99 3d 13h 35m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA TURQUOISE Extra Large 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832320 Homer Laughlin FIESTA TURQUOISE Extra Large 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832320 $29.99 3d 13h 35m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA SCARLET Extra Large 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832388 Homer Laughlin FIESTA SCARLET Extra Large 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832388 $29.99 3d 13h 35m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA COBALT BLUE Extra Large 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832312 Homer Laughlin FIESTA COBALT BLUE Extra Large 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832312 $31.99 3d 13h 35m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA SHAMROCK GREEN Extra Large 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832369 Homer Laughlin FIESTA SHAMROCK GREEN Extra Large 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832369 $29.99 3d 13h 35m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA LEMONGRASS (CONTEMPORARY) XL 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832425 Homer Laughlin FIESTA LEMONGRASS (CONTEMPORARY) XL 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832425 $29.99 3d 14h 56m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA LAPIS BLUE (CONTEMPORARY) XL 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 10033386 Homer Laughlin FIESTA LAPIS BLUE (CONTEMPORARY) XL 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 10033386 $28.19 3d 14h 57m
Fiesta Extra Large Covered Butter Dish in Scarlet Fiestaware Red Fiesta Extra Large Covered Butter Dish in Scarlet Fiestaware Red $25.00 3d 16h 3m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA POPPY (CONTEMPORARY) XL 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 10353324 Homer Laughlin FIESTA POPPY (CONTEMPORARY) XL 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 10353324 $31.99 3d 16h 3m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA SAGE GREEN XL 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 10794436 Homer Laughlin FIESTA SAGE GREEN XL 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 10794436 $29.99 3d 21h 59m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA SLATE (CONTEMPORARY) XL1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 10794332 Homer Laughlin FIESTA SLATE (CONTEMPORARY) XL1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 10794332 $29.99 3d 22h
Homer Laughlin FIESTA COBALT BLUE (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 220806 Homer Laughlin FIESTA COBALT BLUE (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 220806 $31.61 4d 1h 15m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA TURQUOISE (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 221342 Homer Laughlin FIESTA TURQUOISE (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 221342 $33.99 4d 1h 15m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA IVORY (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 6931795 Homer Laughlin FIESTA IVORY (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 6931795 $37.99 4d 2h 13m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA LEMONGRASS (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 8805336 Homer Laughlin FIESTA LEMONGRASS (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 8805336 $29.99 4d 2h 13m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA FLAMINGO (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 9510783 Homer Laughlin FIESTA FLAMINGO (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 9510783 $25.99 4d 2h 19m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA YELLOW (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 988967 Homer Laughlin FIESTA YELLOW (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 988967 $74.95 4d 2h 53m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA PLUM (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 2298842 Homer Laughlin FIESTA PLUM (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 2298842 $45.49 4d 2h 59m
Fiestaware, Extra Large Covered Butter Dish, Fiesta, Scarlet, red, New Seconds Fiestaware, Extra Large Covered Butter Dish, Fiesta, Scarlet, red, New Seconds $24.29 4d 3h 57m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA FLAMINGO (CONTEMPORARY) XL 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832447 Homer Laughlin FIESTA FLAMINGO (CONTEMPORARY) XL 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 9832447 $25.99 4d 3h 57m
Fiestaware, Extra Large Covered Butter Dish, Fiesta, Turquoise, blue, New Second Fiestaware, Extra Large Covered Butter Dish, Fiesta, Turquoise, blue, New Second $24.29 4d 3h 58m
Fiestaware, Small Butter TRAY ONLY, Fiesta, Peacock, blue, New Seconds Fiestaware, Small Butter TRAY ONLY, Fiesta, Peacock, blue, New Seconds $14.39 4d 4h 23m
Fiestaware, Small Butter TRAY ONLY, Fiesta, Peacock, blue, Seconds w/ marks Fiestaware, Small Butter TRAY ONLY, Fiesta, Peacock, blue, Seconds w/ marks $12.59 4d 4h 26m
Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Scarlet, red, Seconds w/ marks Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Scarlet, red, Seconds w/ marks $12.59 4d 4h 35m
Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Scarlet, red, New Seconds Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Scarlet, red, New Seconds $14.39 4d 4h 37m
Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Ivory, cream, New Seconds Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Ivory, cream, New Seconds $14.39 4d 4h 39m
Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Cobalt, blue, New Seconds Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Cobalt, blue, New Seconds $14.39 4d 4h 40m
Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Paprika, brown, burnt orange, New Seconds Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Paprika, brown, burnt orange, New Seconds $14.39 4d 4h 43m
Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Lemongrass, green, New Seconds Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Lemongrass, green, New Seconds $14.39 4d 4h 45m
Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Cinnabar, maroon, burgundy, New Seconds Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Cinnabar, maroon, burgundy, New Seconds $14.39 4d 4h 51m
Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Black, New Seconds Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Black, New Seconds $14.39 4d 4h 52m
Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Plum, purple, New Seconds Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, Plum, purple, New Seconds $13.49 4d 4h 55m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA SUNFLOWER (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 2009484 Homer Laughlin FIESTA SUNFLOWER (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Butter Dish 2009484 $35.99 4d 5h 33m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA SCARLET (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 4037071 Homer Laughlin FIESTA SCARLET (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 4037071 $30.59 4d 5h 57m
Homer Laughlin FIESTA PAPRIKA (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 8592372 Homer Laughlin FIESTA PAPRIKA (CONTEMPORARY) 1/4 Lb Covered Butter Dish 8592372 $29.99 4d 6h 17m
Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Mulberry Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Mulberry $37.95 4d 9h 4m
Chartreuse Butter Tray Only Fiesta Fiestaware Chartreuse Butter Tray Only Fiesta Fiestaware $15.50 4d 13h 4m
Fiesta Fiestaware Baby Blue Covered Butter Dish HLC Pottery Fiesta Fiestaware Baby Blue Covered Butter Dish HLC Pottery $55.00 4d 15h 39m
XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH scarlet red NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH scarlet red NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $28.99 5d 4h 18m
XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH lapis blue NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH lapis blue NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $28.99 5d 4h 20m
BLUE CERAMIC COVERED BUTTER DISH SUGAR CREAMER SALT PEPPER SET BLUE CERAMIC COVERED BUTTER DISH SUGAR CREAMER SALT PEPPER SET $28.50 5d 6h 8m
Fiestaware Two Piece 7 Fiestaware Two Piece 7" Butter Dish Lavender Blue Color - 1 Small Chip on Corner 0 $9.99 5d 8h 54m
Fiestaware Daffodil Butter Dish Fiesta Yellow Covered Butter XL Extra Large Fiestaware Daffodil Butter Dish Fiesta Yellow Covered Butter XL Extra Large $36.00 5d 9h 42m
HLC FIESTA  RED SCARLET EXTRA LARGE COVERED BUTTER DISH HLC FIESTA RED SCARLET EXTRA LARGE COVERED BUTTER DISH $20.00 5d 10h 31m
Fiesta Rose Lidded Butter Dish Marked HLC Fiesta USA Fiesta Rose Lidded Butter Dish Marked HLC Fiesta USA $24.00 5d 10h 46m
NEW FIESTAWARE BUTTER DISH BOTTOM BASE PLATE WHITE SMALL FIESTA RETIRED NEW FIESTAWARE BUTTER DISH BOTTOM BASE PLATE WHITE SMALL FIESTA RETIRED $8.99 5d 12h 17m
Homer Laughlin Co Fiesta Yellow Butter Dish With Lid 1/4 Lb Homer Laughlin Co Fiesta Yellow Butter Dish With Lid 1/4 Lb $54.99 5d 16h 1m
Contemporary Fiestaware Fiesta Pale Yellow Butter Dish New Out Of Box Contemporary Fiestaware Fiesta Pale Yellow Butter Dish New Out Of Box $28.99 6d 1h 41m
Fiesta Fiestaware HLC Cobalt Blue Covered Butter Dish Made in USA Fiesta Fiestaware HLC Cobalt Blue Covered Butter Dish Made in USA $35.99 6d 4h 46m
Fiesta Covered Butter Dish Indiglo Blue Fiesta Covered Butter Dish Indiglo Blue $25.00 6d 5h 5m
XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH ivory NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH ivory NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $28.99 6d 6h 21m
Mint Lilac Butter Dish with Cover Mint Lilac Butter Dish with Cover 0 $15.00 6d 7h 17m
Fiestaware Scarlett Butter Dish Fiestaware Scarlett Butter Dish $10.00 6d 7h 37m
COVERED BUTTER DISH cobalt blue NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA COVERED BUTTER DISH cobalt blue NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $34.99 6d 7h 57m
PLUM FIESTA COVERED BUTTER DISH ~ NWT PLUM FIESTA COVERED BUTTER DISH ~ NWT $54.99 6d 8h 49m
Fiesta XL Covered Butter Dish Slate New Fiestaware Fiesta XL Covered Butter Dish Slate New Fiestaware $27.00 6d 13h 58m
Fiesta XL Covered Butter Dish Sunflower  NEW Never Used Fiesta Fiesta XL Covered Butter Dish Sunflower NEW Never Used Fiesta $27.00 6d 13h 58m
FIESTAWARE Lime Green Butter Tray Only • EUC FIESTAWARE Lime Green Butter Tray Only • EUC $9.99 8d 3h 57m
Fiesta Ware Scarlet Butter Dish Extra Large No Lid and Salt & Pepper Fiestaware Fiesta Ware Scarlet Butter Dish Extra Large No Lid and Salt & Pepper Fiestaware $14.99 8d 4h 56m
Homer Laughlin Fiesta Lemongrass XL covered butter dish with original tag NEW Homer Laughlin Fiesta Lemongrass XL covered butter dish with original tag NEW $19.99 8d 4h 56m
New FIESTA Homer Laughlin Small  Turquoise Covered Butter Dish  New FIESTA Homer Laughlin Small Turquoise Covered Butter Dish $28.89 8d 5h 38m
Fiesta Homer Laughlin Fiestaware ART DECO BLACK 1/4 pound Covered Butter Dish Fiesta Homer Laughlin Fiestaware ART DECO BLACK 1/4 pound Covered Butter Dish 0 $29.99 8d 6h 52m
Fiestaware Cobalt Blue XL Butter Dish - Fiesta HLC Extra Large Blue Butterdish Fiestaware Cobalt Blue XL Butter Dish - Fiesta HLC Extra Large Blue Butterdish $49.95 8d 9h 7m
Fiesta Daffodil XL Butter Dish Fiesta Retired Orange Small Covered Butter Dish Fiesta Daffodil XL Butter Dish Fiesta Retired Orange Small Covered Butter Dish $23.39 8d 9h 18m
NIB*Fiestaware*Fiesta Ware* CHARTREUSE  Butter Dish*16316Y NIB*Fiestaware*Fiesta Ware* CHARTREUSE Butter Dish*16316Y $48.00 8d 10h 44m
Fiesta Tangerine Butter Dish Retired Color Excellent 1st Qual Orange Fiestaware Fiesta Tangerine Butter Dish Retired Color Excellent 1st Qual Orange Fiestaware $36.99 8d 10h 46m
fiesta butter dish lid TURQUOISE BLUE Homer Laughlin made in USA contemporary fiesta butter dish lid TURQUOISE BLUE Homer Laughlin made in USA contemporary $19.99 8d 11h 2m
Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Sunflower Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish | Sunflower $37.95 9d 5h 8m
Fiestaware Lemongrass Butter Dish Fiesta Green XL Extra Large Butter Dish Fiestaware Lemongrass Butter Dish Fiesta Green XL Extra Large Butter Dish $27.00 9d 5h 55m
Fiestaware SUNFLOWER Yellow Butter Dish Tray / Base Only Fiesta Homer Laughlin Fiestaware SUNFLOWER Yellow Butter Dish Tray / Base Only Fiesta Homer Laughlin $12.50 9d 6h 55m
Fiestaware Fiesta Cobalt Blue Covered Butter Dish, Excellent Condition! Fiestaware Fiesta Cobalt Blue Covered Butter Dish, Excellent Condition! $34.95 9d 9h 33m

Texas Cooking is a proud member of the Homer Laughlin China Collectors Association If you are interested in collecting this great dinnerware, look into this great organization.

Fiesta® is a registered trademark of the Homer Laughlin China Company, Newell WV. This website and its pages are not owned by Homer Laughlin China Company. We do not pretend to officially represent the Homer Laughlin China Company. They are the official experts - not us! We are simply enthusiastic collectors and fans of the china.