Texas Cooking Logo

Fiesta® Butter Dish (Post 1986)

Butter Dish Production: -

by

Fiesta Butter Dish
Wow! I can't believe it's not a butter dish!
Fiesta collector

Guns and Butter

HLC added the butter dish to the Fiesta line in 1992. Since then, the company has made several small modifications to the shape of the dish's base, rounding the corners. In 2012 HLC added a second butter dish to the line, larger in size, to accommodate larger sizes of butter sold in parts of the United States. After a successful run, the company announced that they would officially transition to the larger 1431 covered butter dish. On May 31, 2013, along with a handful of other items, they would cease production of the 494 covered butter dish.

The Post86 Covered Butter is item number 494 (Base 716 Lid 717).

FIESTA FLAMINGO LARGE COVERED BUTTER DISH FIESTA FLAMINGO LARGE COVERED BUTTER DISH $24.95 4h 7m
Fiestaware Flamingo Butter dish Fiesta Pink Covered Butter XL Extra Large Fiestaware Flamingo Butter dish Fiesta Pink Covered Butter XL Extra Large $30.00 4h 26m
FIESTAWARE Lime Green Butter Tray Only • EUC FIESTAWARE Lime Green Butter Tray Only • EUC 0 $9.99 4h 41m
Fiesta Turquoise Covered Butter Dish 1st Quality Fiesta Turquoise Covered Butter Dish 1st Quality $24.95 5h 16m
VTG VTG "OLD McDONALD FARM" BUTTER DISH $26.00 9h 24m
Fiestaware Tangerine Butter Dish Fiesta Retired Orange Small Covered Butter NWT Fiestaware Tangerine Butter Dish Fiesta Retired Orange Small Covered Butter NWT $34.00 9h 58m
FIESTA YELLOW CORNFLOWER BUTTER DISH WITH LID FIESTA YELLOW CORNFLOWER BUTTER DISH WITH LID 0 $15.00 11h 39m
Fiesta Butter Dish with Lid Excellent Condition Fiesta Butter Dish with Lid Excellent Condition 0 $16.50 17h 15m
XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH shamrock green NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH shamrock green NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $28.99 1d 6h 20m
Fiestaware Covered Butter dish Blue Fiestaware Covered Butter dish Blue 0 $19.99 1d 14h 16m
Fiesta BUTTER DISH BOTTOM- Original Size -Discontinued Item - 2nd - CHOCOLATE Fiesta BUTTER DISH BOTTOM- Original Size -Discontinued Item - 2nd - CHOCOLATE $10.00 2d 4h 56m
Fiesta BUTTER DISH TOP- Original Size -Discontinued Item - 2nd - EVERGEEN Fiesta BUTTER DISH TOP- Original Size -Discontinued Item - 2nd - EVERGEEN $10.00 2d 5h 7m
Fiestaware 2019 NEW Color MEADOW  XL Butter Dish Fiestaware 2019 NEW Color MEADOW  XL Butter Dish 0 $30.00 2d 8h 24m
Vintage Fiesta Green  Covered Butter Dish Fiestaware Preowned Vintage Fiesta Green Covered Butter Dish Fiestaware Preowned 0 $5.30 2d 13h 39m
Fiesta® WHITE Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item Fiesta® WHITE Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item $9.89 2d 17h 43m
Fiesta® SUNFLOWER Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item Fiesta® SUNFLOWER Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item $10.99 2d 17h 53m
Fiesta® IVORY Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item Fiesta® IVORY Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item $9.89 2d 18h 3m
Fiesta® MARIGOLD Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item Fiesta® MARIGOLD Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item $14.39 2d 18h 13m
Fiesta® CHOCOLATE Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item Fiesta® CHOCOLATE Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item $13.99 2d 18h 23m
Fiesta® EVERGREEN Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item Fiesta® EVERGREEN Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item $12.99 2d 18h 33m
Fiesta® PAPRIKA Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item Fiesta® PAPRIKA Post 86 Small Butter Dish Tray / Base - Discontinued Item $12.99 2d 18h 43m
COBALT Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray COBALT Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray $14.99 2d 18h 53m
SHAMROCK Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray SHAMROCK Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray $13.49 2d 19h 3m
POPPY Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray POPPY Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray $14.99 2d 19h 13m
SCARLET Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray SCARLET Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray $13.49 2d 19h 23m
TURQUOISE Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray TURQUOISE Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray $13.49 2d 19h 33m
PLUM Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray PLUM Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray $17.09 2d 19h 43m
TANGERINE Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray TANGERINE Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray $18.99 2d 19h 53m
MARIGOLD Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray MARIGOLD Fiesta® Extra Large Butter Dish TRAY ONLY - Great side plate / tray $18.99 2d 20h 3m
Retired Fiesta Butter Dish White Cream Retired Fiesta Butter Dish White Cream 0 $21.59 3d 3h
Covered Butter Dish Scarlet Red NWT Contemporary Fiesta Ware XL 8 Covered Butter Dish Scarlet Red NWT Contemporary Fiesta Ware XL 8" Ceramic $35.99 3d 5h 36m
Fiestaware Flamingo Butter Dish Fiesta Extra Large XL Retired Pink Fiestaware Flamingo Butter Dish Fiesta Extra Large XL Retired Pink $39.00 3d 5h 52m
2-PC FIESTA DEEP 2-PC FIESTA DEEP "COBALT BLUE" 8" BUTTER DISH & LID/HOMER LAUGHLIN/USA/FREE SHIP $37.95 3d 5h 59m
Fiesta Ware SEA MIST Lot ~ 40 oz Bowl 19 oz soup bowl cup & saucer Butter Dish Fiesta Ware SEA MIST Lot ~ 40 oz Bowl 19 oz soup bowl cup & saucer Butter Dish 1 $29.99 3d 6h 27m
HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA FIESTAWARE Scarlet Red COVERED BUTTER DISH HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA FIESTAWARE Scarlet Red COVERED BUTTER DISH 0 $14.95 3d 6h 47m
XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH tangerine orange NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH tangerine orange NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $28.99 3d 7h 45m
Fiestaware Ivory Butter dish Fiesta Off White Covered Butter XL Extra Large Fiestaware Ivory Butter dish Fiesta Off White Covered Butter XL Extra Large $27.50 3d 8h 25m
HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA FIESTAWARE Scarlet Red COVERED BUTTER DISH HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA FIESTAWARE Scarlet Red COVERED BUTTER DISH 0 $22.00 3d 9h 36m
Vintage Purple Fiestaware Ramekin Vintage Purple Fiestaware Ramekin 0 $6.00 3d 14h 11m
NEW FIESTAWARE BUTTER DISH BOTTOM BASE PLATE LEMONGRASS SMALL FIESTA RETIRED NEW FIESTAWARE BUTTER DISH BOTTOM BASE PLATE LEMONGRASS SMALL FIESTA RETIRED $8.99 4d 5h 2m
FLAMINGO Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set - Discontinued Color FLAMINGO Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set - Discontinued Color $29.99 4d 5h 38m
Fiesta Turquoise Butter Dish Plate Tray Only USA J Fiestaware Fiesta Turquoise Butter Dish Plate Tray Only USA J Fiestaware $14.99 4d 5h 51m
XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH mulberry purple NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH mulberry purple NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $28.99 4d 6h 57m
SAGE Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set SAGE Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set $24.99 4d 8h 38m
SUNFLOWER Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set - 1st Quality SUNFLOWER Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set - 1st Quality $29.99 4d 10h 8m
SHAMROCK Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set SHAMROCK Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set $24.99 4d 13h 38m
TANGERINE Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set Discontinued Color - 1st TANGERINE Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set Discontinued Color - 1st $39.99 4d 14h 8m
SUNFLOWER Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set SUNFLOWER Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set $24.99 4d 16h 8m
POPPY Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set - 1st Quality POPPY Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set - 1st Quality $29.99 4d 17h 8m
LEMONGRASS Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set - 1st Quality LEMONGRASS Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set - 1st Quality $29.99 4d 23h 8m
MARIGOLD Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set Discontinued Color - 1st MARIGOLD Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set Discontinued Color - 1st $39.99 5d 3h 8m
LAPIS Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set LAPIS Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set $24.99 5d 3h 38m
PAPRIKA Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set PAPRIKA Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set $29.99 5d 4h 38m
LAPIS Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set - 1st Quality LAPIS Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set - 1st Quality $29.99 5d 9h 23m
COVERED BUTTER DISH chocolate brown NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA COVERED BUTTER DISH chocolate brown NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $39.99 5d 10h 25m
Fiestaware Tangerine Butter Dish Fiesta Orange Covered Butter XL Large Fiestaware Tangerine Butter Dish Fiesta Orange Covered Butter XL Large $35.00 5d 11h 9m
Fiestaware Lemongrass Butter Dish Fiesta Lime Covered Butter XL Large Fiestaware Lemongrass Butter Dish Fiesta Lime Covered Butter XL Large $25.00 5d 11h 10m
Fiestaware Lapis Butter Dish Fiesta XL Extra Large Blue Butter Dish Fiestaware Lapis Butter Dish Fiesta XL Extra Large Blue Butter Dish $27.00 5d 13h
Fiestaware Chartreuse Small Butter Dish Fiesta Lime  1/4 Lb. Covered Butter Fiestaware Chartreuse Small Butter Dish Fiesta Lime 1/4 Lb. Covered Butter $35.00 5d 13h 33m
FIESTA CHRISTMAS BUTTER DISH Cream Holiday Extra Large Lid Tray ~Brand New~ FIESTA CHRISTMAS BUTTER DISH Cream Holiday Extra Large Lid Tray ~Brand New~ $24.95 5d 15h 13m
Fiesta Yellow Butter Dish Bottom only First Quality Retired Color Fiesta Yellow Butter Dish Bottom only First Quality Retired Color $7.00 5d 19h 24m
Fiestaware Mulberry Butter Dish Fiesta XL Purple Extra Large Butter Dish Fiestaware Mulberry Butter Dish Fiesta XL Purple Extra Large Butter Dish $29.00 6d 5h 8m
Fiesta Green Butter Dish Homer Laughlin No Lid Fiesta Green Butter Dish Homer Laughlin No Lid $14.99 6d 5h 9m
COVERED BUTTER DISH paprika NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA COVERED BUTTER DISH paprika NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $39.99 6d 6h 8m
Mint Condition Extra Large HLC Fiesta USA Pink Covered Butter Dish Lid Plate Mint Condition Extra Large HLC Fiesta USA Pink Covered Butter Dish Lid Plate $41.99 6d 6h 45m
FIESTA Retired SAGE X-Large Covered Butter Dish LID / NEW Unused FIESTA Retired SAGE X-Large Covered Butter Dish LID / NEW Unused $17.99 6d 7h 45m
Vintage HLC Fiestaware USA Blue Coved Butter Dish Pre-owned Vintage HLC Fiestaware USA Blue Coved Butter Dish Pre-owned $20.00 6d 10h 1m
Fiestaware Tangerine Butter Dish Fiesta Retired Orange Small Covered Butter Dish Fiestaware Tangerine Butter Dish Fiesta Retired Orange Small Covered Butter Dish $36.99 6d 10h 23m
Fiestaware Cobalt Small Covered Butter Dish Fiestaware Cobalt Small Covered Butter Dish $29.99 6d 10h 45m
FIESTA WARE   BUTTER  DISH  H. L. C.  COBALT  BLUE   USA FIESTA WARE BUTTER DISH H. L. C. COBALT BLUE USA $24.00 6d 11h 44m
Fiesta Ivory small butter dish base tray Fiesta Ivory small butter dish base tray $10.00 6d 12h 14m
Fiestaware Daffodil Butter Dish Fiesta Yellow Covered Butter XL Extra Large Fiestaware Daffodil Butter Dish Fiesta Yellow Covered Butter XL Extra Large $40.00 6d 12h 44m
Fiestaware Tangerine Butter Dish Fiesta  Retired Orange Butter approx 8 Fiestaware Tangerine Butter Dish Fiesta Retired Orange Butter approx 8" by 5" $24.95 6d 23h 21m
Fiestaware Lapis Butter dish Fiesta Blue Butter XL Extra Large Fiestaware Lapis Butter dish Fiesta Blue Butter XL Extra Large $20.00 7d 2h 57m
Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, White, New Seconds Fiestaware, Small Butter Tray, Fiesta, White, New Seconds $14.99 7d 3h 35m
Fiestaware, Discontinued, Small Butter Dish, Fiesta, White Fiestaware, Discontinued, Small Butter Dish, Fiesta, White $26.99 7d 4h 20m
Fiestaware White Butter dish Fiesta White Covered Butter XL Extra Large Fiestaware White Butter dish Fiesta White Covered Butter XL Extra Large $27.50 7d 6h 5m
Fiestaware Sage Butter Dish Fiesta XL Extra Large Butter Dish Retired Green NEW Fiestaware Sage Butter Dish Fiesta XL Extra Large Butter Dish Retired Green NEW $45.00 7d 6h 59m
LEMONGRASS Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set LEMONGRASS Fiesta® Extra Large Covered Butter Dish Set $24.99 7d 7h 53m
FIESTA/FIESTAWARE BLUE And Burgundy  PIECE BUTTERDISH HOMER LAUGHLIN USA FIESTA/FIESTAWARE BLUE And Burgundy PIECE BUTTERDISH HOMER LAUGHLIN USA 0 $17.00 8d 9h 19m
Fiesta Ware Butter Dish No Lid Fiestaware Tangerine Extra Large Retired Color Fiesta Ware Butter Dish No Lid Fiestaware Tangerine Extra Large Retired Color $9.99 8d 13h 6m
fiestaware Butter Dish fiestaware Butter Dish $27.00 8d 13h 26m
 Fiestaware Cobalt Blue extra Large Covered Butter Dish Fiestaware Cobalt Blue extra Large Covered Butter Dish $21.99 8d 13h 32m
Fiestaware Turquoise Butter Dish Fiesta XL Blue Extra Large Butter Dish Fiestaware Turquoise Butter Dish Fiesta XL Blue Extra Large Butter Dish $28.50 8d 13h 39m
FIESTAWARE Sunflower Yellow  BUTTER DISH BOTTOM BASE PLATE ONLY Free Shipping FIESTAWARE Sunflower Yellow BUTTER DISH BOTTOM BASE PLATE ONLY Free Shipping $24.99 9d 2h 49m
Fiestaware Sunflower Butter Dish Fiesta XL Yellow Extra Large Butter Dish Fiestaware Sunflower Butter Dish Fiesta XL Yellow Extra Large Butter Dish $29.00 9d 2h 55m
Homer Laughlin Fiesta TANGERINE Small Butter Lid Only Homer Laughlin Fiesta TANGERINE Small Butter Lid Only $8.00 9d 5h 23m
XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH marigold NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH marigold NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $32.99 9d 5h 35m
XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH white NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH white NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $28.99 9d 5h 42m
XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH cobalt NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA XL extra large COVERED BUTTER DISH cobalt NEW HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $28.99 9d 5h 46m
Fiestaware, Discontinued, Small Butter Dish, Fiesta, Periwinkle, blue Fiestaware, Discontinued, Small Butter Dish, Fiesta, Periwinkle, blue $24.99 9d 6h 11m
Fiesta BUTTER DISH -Original Size -Discontinued Item & Color-First quality- PLUM Fiesta BUTTER DISH -Original Size -Discontinued Item & Color-First quality- PLUM $50.00 9d 7h 4m
Fiestaware Turquoise Butter dish Fiesta Blue Covered Butter XL Extra Large Fiestaware Turquoise Butter dish Fiesta Blue Covered Butter XL Extra Large $27.50 9d 8h 1m
 Fiesta®  Covered Butter Dish  Fiesta® Covered Butter Dish 0 $19.99 9d 8h 15m
Fiestaware Scarlet Butter Dish Red XL Extra Large Butter Dish From Macy’s Fiestaware Scarlet Butter Dish Red XL Extra Large Butter Dish From Macy’s $22.00 9d 8h 34m
FIESTA butter dish white 8 FIESTA butter dish white 8" x 5" - broken handle fiestaware - includes handle $7.99 9d 10h 54m
FIESTAWARE PInk Rose BUTTER DISH BOTTOM BASE PLATE ONLY FIESTAWARE PInk Rose BUTTER DISH BOTTOM BASE PLATE ONLY $18.50 9d 13h 15m
Small COVERED BUTTER DISH  NEW PAPRIKA  HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA Small COVERED BUTTER DISH NEW PAPRIKA HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $34.99 10d 6h 54m
Small COVERED BUTTER DISH  NEW COBALT HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA Small COVERED BUTTER DISH NEW COBALT HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $34.99 10d 6h 55m
Small COVERED BUTTER DISH  NEW SCARLET HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA Small COVERED BUTTER DISH NEW SCARLET HOMER LAUGHLIN FIESTA $34.99 10d 6h 56m

Texas Cooking is a proud member of the Homer Laughlin China Collectors Association If you are interested in collecting this great dinnerware, look into this great organization.

Fiesta® is a registered trademark of the Homer Laughlin China Company, Newell WV. This website and its pages are not owned by Homer Laughlin China Company. We do not pretend to officially represent the Homer Laughlin China Company. They are the official experts - not us! We are simply enthusiastic collectors and fans of the china.

Follow Texas Cooking: